Knowledge

Are You Fixing Your Biggest Production Loss, or Just the Most Visible One?

Written by Gerrit Jan Wilpshaar | Nov 17, 2026, 7:00:03 AM

When a pipe extrusion line stops, everyone notices. Production is interrupted, operators investigate, and every minute of downtime counts. But what happens when a line runs smoothly and produces pipes that consistently use more material than necessary?

Often, it attracts far less attention. The pipes meet specifications, production continues, and the extra material becomes part of a product sold to the customer. Yet that extra material leaves the factory every day, adding costs that can easily go unnoticed.

Does that extra material get the same attention as a production stop?

 

The hidden cost of producing good pipe

Consider a production program with a nominal material requirement of 10,000 tonnes of PVC per year. At 6% overweight, material consumption would be 10,600 tonnes. Reducing that to 3% would bring consumption down to 10,300 tonnes. That represents 300 tonnes of PVC, or €330,000 in potential annual savings at an illustrative material price of €1.10 per kilogram. The same quantity of pipe, produced with less material.

These figures are illustrative. Whether a reduction from 6% to 3% is achievable depends on the products, equipment, and production conditions. Still, the example shows how a few percentage points can add up over a year.

Reducing overweight, however, isn't simply a matter of adjusting extruder settings. Pipes must meet minimum wall thickness requirements and other product specifications. Because wall thickness is never perfectly uniform, operators need a margin to accommodate process variations. If the variation is too large, lowering the average weight could leave some sections below the required minimum.

More consistent wall thickness can allow a lower average pipe weight while keeping the thinnest sections within specification. Before deciding how much material can be saved, producers need to understand what causes the variation and how much they can realistically reduce it.

Improving process stability does not automatically reduce material consumption. A line may produce more consistent wall thickness while operators continue using the same target pipe weight. In that case, the technical improvement has not yet translated into material savings. Regularly reviewing target weights against actual process variation and product requirements can help identify opportunities that might otherwise go unnoticed.



Where should your next improvement start?

The largest potential saving is not automatically the best investment. An improvement requiring major modifications and significant downtime may be less attractive than a smaller change that delivers savings sooner. Before choosing a technical solution, it helps to put a cost on the problem. What is the annual cost? How much of that loss can you realistically eliminate? And what investment or operational changes would be required? The answers make it easier to compare improvements and decide which to investigate first.

The Rollepaal ROI Calculator helps quantify this opportunity for material efficiency. By entering annual production figures, current and target overweight, and material price, producers can estimate potential annual material savings. Whether those savings are achievable requires a closer look at the production process. Comparing the potential savings with the required investment and implementation costs helps build a realistic business case.

Assigning a yearly cost to excess pipe weight puts it in the same discussion as downtime, scrap, and output. Before deciding where to invest in your next production improvement, find out what unnecessary material consumption could be costing you.